I was fortunate enough to view a screening of the new Snowden movie Wednesday evening with some of the whistleblowers who have cameos in it and with its director Oliver Stone. I’m not allowed to review it until Saturday night, but it is a truly great movie and has the potential to be the most widely seen, heard, or read thing of any political decency or truth in the world this year. That’s not, however, why I’m glad I saw it.
I’m glad I watched Snowden because it gave me an extra several hours of living on earth without having yet seen the NBC special on the Trumpillary war machine, in which first Hillary Clinton and then Donald Trump promised NBC they’d wage plenty of wars. Earlier, on Wednesday I had posted this on my Facebook page:
Here are a few of my favorite facts that you will not learn tonight from NBC, Donald Trump, or Hillary Clinton: Nonviolent resistance is more effective than violence and its victories longer lasting. Peaceful spending or even tax cuts for working people is economically superior to military spending. The war on terrorism has increased terrorism, including in the seven nations the United States has bombed this year.
Over half of federal discretionary spending, through multiple departments, is dumped into war preparations each year, about as much as the rest of the world’s nations combined. The US is the top arms dealer to dictatorships abroad, and today’s wars typically have US weapons on both sides.
The US Army can’t figure out what it did with $6.5 trillion this year, while the United Nations says that $30 billion a year could end starvation on earth. Every recent US war has been illegal under the U.N. Charter and the Kellogg Briand Pact. Over 95% of the victims of every recent US war have been on the other side, and the vast majority of them civilian.
The top destroyer of the natural environment is the US military. Routinely bombing Muslim countries, giving war weapons and war training to local police, and expecting non-racist, law-abiding policing cannot work. The US backed a violent coup in Ukraine. Sitting out the National Anthem is not “true patriotism” but a truly courageous challenge to the poison of patriotism.
NBC did not disappoint. Matt Lauer did not ask Trumpillary how much money, even within a quarter trillion dollars or so, they would like spent. He did not ask which wars, if any, they would end or start. He did not ask how many people they would murder with drones. He did not ask if they would kidnap or torture or murder in prisons. He did not ask about foreign aid. He did not ask about leading by example. He did not ask about climate change. He did not ask about the arms trade or the bombing of Yemen. He did not ask about the announcement ISIS had just made of having named a US-trained (and, of course, US-armed) sniper as its Minister of War. He did not ask about the racism and violence permeating US culture. I don’t think any of the three people (Clinton, Trump, Lauer) or any of the veterans asking questions ever said the word “peace.”
Lauer opened by claiming that September 11th launched years of war. In fact, the US government launched years of war.
NBC then showed clips of 9/11 and of Obama announcing the killing of Osama bin Laden, but not a single image of a single body or bombed out house. After 15 years of immoral, illegal, catastrophic murder sprees, Clinton began by taking credit for her “experience” of having been part of making all those wars happen.
So, Lauer asked her, not about any of those wars, but about her emails. Eventually he turned to Iraq, and she claimed to have learned her lesson. Although she still wanted war in Libya and several other countries and still wants it badly in Syria (though Lauer didn’t get into that), so she’s clearly learned nothing. She did claim accurately that Trump backed war on Iraq and Libya too, while still claiming inaccurately that Gaddafi was planning a massacre. Lauer confirmed and corrected nothing.
What if Iran cheats on its nuclear agreement, Lauer wanted to know. Clinton then lied about Iranian hostility, blamed Iran for supporting Syria against US-backed attacks, and “improved” Ronald Reagan’s phrase to “distrust but verify.”
Clinton promised no ground troops in Iraq, but there already are US ground troops in Iraq. Lauer said nothing. Clinton promised to “go after” ISIS leader Baghdadi for the purpose of “focusing our attention.” This is war for propaganda, not just propaganda for war.
Turning to Trump, he opened by claiming that Russian planes and Iranian ships are taunting the United States. Remind me again which coast of the United States the Baltic Sea and the Persian Gulf are on.
Trump then lied that he opposed attacking Iraq. Lauer said . . . (you guessed it) nothing. Trump also, if at odds with that lie, lied that Obama ended the war on Iraq and that so doing was a terrible thing.
Trump claimed, with as straight a face as he can manage, that it was a big success for him that the people who brought him to Mexico have now been thrown out of the government as a result.
A pre-approved veteran asked Trump how “defeating” a terrorist group won’t just produce a new one. Trump talked a while without answering and then said, “Take the Oil.” Steal Iraq’s oil. That was Trump’s answer. If you steal their oil, then they can’t have any power, he suggested. Trump seemed to believe no hostility or resentment would find any leverage after such a theft, that such a theft could be completed quickly, and that he was providing us with new information as “people don’t know this about Iraq” (that it has among the world’s largest reserves of oil).
Lauer asked Trump if he really has a plan to “defeat ISIS.” It was clear he does not.
NBC had a veteran ask how Trump would deescalate tensions with Russia. He answered by claiming Russian airplanes are engaged in hostility against the United States. That ought to do it.
Then Lauer piled on, falsely and baselessly blaming Putin for aggression in Ukraine and interference in the US election, and blaming Russia for supporting Syria and Iran.
Lauer and vets asked Trumpillary about caring for veterans, all taking it as unquestionable that more veterans must be produced through more wars. Trump even said that he’d let immigrants remain in the United States if they would “serve” . . . not his dinner apparently, but his war machine, Hillary’s war machine, NBC’s war machine, Comcast’s war machine, the war machine of people who’ve watched this stuff for 15 years and started to believe it’s the way normal decent human beings should be allowed to behave.
Reprinted with permission from DavidSwanson.org.
